Best Brokers

Broker review

Merrill Edge Self-Directed review

Zero-commission investing wired into Bank of America, with a $49.95 charge to move the account out.

Published
Data verified

In summary

Merrill Edge Self-Directed accounts are held with Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner & Smith Incorporated, an active SEC-registered broker-dealer and SIPC member with one of the longest registration histories in our set. Online stock, ETF and options trades carry no base commission, options are $0.65 per contract, and there is no trade or balance minimum. Transferring the full account out costs $49.95.

Editorial score, based on our methodology

How this is calculated
Score composition, out of 10Safety and regulation contributes 2.7 of 7.6. Fees and total cost contributes 2.1 of 7.6. Investment selection contributes 1.3 of 7.6. Account types and features contributes 1.4 of 7.6. The full breakdown is in the table below.
  • Safety2.7
  • Cost2.1
  • Selection1.3
  • Accounts1.4
  • Headroom2.4
How the total is built · Segment width = sub-score × weight. Widths sum to the total.

Legal entity and regulation

Read from FINRA BrokerCheck on August 28, 2026. Check it yourself — the reference number below is all you need.

Legal name
MERRILL LYNCH, PIERCE, FENNER & SMITH INCORPORATED
CRD
7691
SEC
8-7221
Registration status
ACTIVE
Regulators
SEC, FINRA
Investor protection
SIPC member — up to $500,000, including $250,000 for cash

Published fees

9 of 14 fields verified

Read from Merrill Edge Self-Directed’s own published schedule. Fields we could not find on the pages we read are marked not verified — we do not fill them with estimates, and a blank would read as zero.

Merrill Edge Self-Directed published fee schedule
US stocks and ETFs$0Online, no trade or balance minimums
Options base commission$0
Options per contract$0.65
Account minimum$0No minimum for general investing accounts
Mutual funds$0 no-load NTF and load-waived; $19.95 no-load transaction-fee fundsOnline. $39.95 short-term redemption fee on NTF funds held under 90 days
BondsNot verified
FuturesNot offered
CryptoNot offered
Account service feeNone published
Inactivity feeNone published
Outgoing transfer fee$49.95 full account; $0 partial
Broker-assisted trade$29.95
Margin rateNot verified
Currency conversionNot verified

Where these costs sit

Against every other broker we publish that has a verified figure for the same field. Brokers whose figure we could not verify are left out rather than plotted at zero.

$0cheapest$1most expensive
Options, per contract · 12 brokers with a verified figure
$0cheapest$2,000most expensive
Account minimum · 7 brokers with a verified figure

What you can hold

  • US stocksOffered
  • ETFsOffered
  • OptionsOffered
  • Mutual fundsOffered
  • BondsOffered
  • FuturesNot offered
  • Spot currenciesNot offered
  • CryptoNot offered
  • International listingsNot offered
  • Fractional sharesNot verified
  • OTC equitiesNot offered

Account types

  • Individual taxable offered
  • Joint offered
  • Traditional IRA offered
  • Roth IRA offered
  • Rollover IRA offered
  • SEP / SIMPLE IRA offered
  • Custodial offered
  • Trust offered
  • Solo 401(k) not offered
  • HSA not offered
  • Margin offered
  • Managed portfolio offered

Strengths and limitations

Strengths

  • $0 online stock, ETF and options base commissions with no trade or balance minimum
  • Very long registration history under a well-capitalised parent
  • Partial account transfers out are free
  • Merrill Guided Investing at 0.45% from a $1,000 minimum, or 0.85% with an advisor

Limitations

  • $49.95 to transfer the full account out
  • $19.95 per online trade on no-load transaction-fee mutual funds, plus a $39.95 short-term redemption fee under 90 days
  • No futures and no crypto
  • $24.95 wire transfer fee

Check these yourself

  • Bank of America Preferred Rewards tiers are referenced on the pricing page but the specific benefits are documented elsewhere — check what your balance tier actually changes
  • Broker-assisted trades cost $29.95, among the highest we recorded

How Merrill Edge Self-Directed scores

Under our default weights. Individual rankings re-weight these same sub-scores, which is why Merrill Edge Self-Directed sits in different positions on different pages.

  • Safety and regulationweight 30%
    9/10
  • Fees and total costweight 30%
    7/10
  • Investment selectionweight 22%
    6/10
  • Account types and featuresweight 18%
    8/10
Sub-scores by pillar · Each pillar scored 0–10 from published evidence
Safety and regulation9/10 · weighted 30%
Active SEC-registered broker-dealer (8-7221) — the lowest SEC file number in our set, indicating a very long registration history — and a SIPC member within Bank of America. No headline retail enforcement matter identified in our sourced review.
Fees and total cost7/10 · weighted 30%
$0 online stock, ETF and options base commissions with a $0.65 contract fee and no balance minimum. Marked down for a $49.95 full account transfer fee, $24.95 wires, $19.95 transaction-fee funds and a $29.95 broker-assisted charge — a fee surface materially larger than the cheapest firms in our set.
Investment selection6/10 · weighted 22%
Stocks, ETFs, options, bonds and a large mutual fund range are published. No futures and no crypto. Fractional shares were not confirmed on the pricing page we read.
Account types and features8/10 · weighted 18%
Full retail lineup including all IRA variants, custodial and trust accounts, plus Merrill Guided Investing at 0.45% from a $1,000 minimum. No HSA or solo 401(k) identified.

Not scored

  • Access and eligibility Not scored in v1.0. Requires per-country eligibility confirmed against each firm's own onboarding terms, which we have not completed.
  • Platform and usability Not scored in v1.0. Requires hands-on use of a funded account, which we have not done.
  • Research and education Not scored in v1.0. Requires logged-in access to the research suite, which we have not had.
  • Customer service Not scored in v1.0. Requires timed contact tests across channels, which we have not run.
  • Execution quality Not scored in v1.0. Requires analysis of Rule 605/606 order-execution reports, which is scheduled for a later release.

Sources

  1. [1]Merrill — PricingRead August 28, 2026
  2. [2]FINRA BrokerCheck — Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner & Smith IncorporatedRead August 28, 2026

Affiliate disclosure

We currently have no affiliate or commercial relationship with any broker on this site, and every outbound link is a plain link. If that changes, it will be disclosed here and on the broker's row. Read the full disclosure.

Risk warning

Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Nothing on this site is personalized investment advice, a recommendation to buy or sell any security, or a solicitation. Figures are read from public sources on the dates shown and can change without notice — verify anything you intend to act on with the provider directly. Read the full risk disclosure.